9.30.2009

Enormity

 In a recent mini-blog post Seth Godin makes the following observation:
Enormity,
Enormity doesn't mean really enormous. It means incredibly horrible. 
The problem with enormity in marketing is that it doesn't work. Enormity should pull at our heartstrings, but it usually shuts us down.
Show us too many sick kids, unfair imprisonments or burned bodies and you won't get a bigger donation, you'll just get averted eyes. 
If you've got a small, fixable problem, people will rush to help, because people like to be on the winning side, take credit and do something that worked. If you've got a generational problem, something that is going to take herculean effort and even then probably won't pan out, we're going to move on in search of something smaller. 
Not fair, but true.
I thank Seth for bringing this to my attention, this is a social reality, something we need to deal with, something we need to take into account. As I’ve thought about it, after first being angry at the messenger, “Those damn marketers!” I realized the problem goes much deeper. Sure marketing, a profession built up over the last four or five score years, has become a leading force in shaping how we see the world and orient ourselves to it.  It has long been busy finding ways to usurp basic human drives, and sell the resultant insights to those who want to take advantage of us; but even that is just another human drive, an expression of humanity prevalent during a particular kind of extremis.

Enormity. It doesn’t “sell.” Yet enormity is what we’re facing, on many levels and from all sides. That’s what happens at the end of an Era, at the start of a new one. No one likes to have to accommodate to unpleasantness. It’s like getting bad news from the doctor,

“I don’t have time for that now, I have plans!”

If we haven’t been there yet, we can all imagine it, have seen it happen to relatives, friends…. It does no good to demonize people for this kind of reaction, placing blame, working up guilt will not help the situation. No one is at their best when they feel attacked. How do we expect ourselves, or anyone else, to rise to Enormity if in our desire to motivate we pile on layers of bad-feeling, remorse, atop the, well, the Enormity we face?

Of course, marketing has long used a similar cycle to manipulate us for their bosses. Point out reasons for dissatisfaction with the status quo – within very narrow and lucrative parameters – and develop a sense of crisis, make us feel that without an answer – the answer they’re selling – our lives will be tragic, shallow and meaningless. This last part has been abbreviated into expressions like “relevant,” “current,” even simply “happy.” By placing us in ever-heightening cycles of dissatisfaction, an ever-more hyper search for an easily purchased appeasement of our anxiety, exhorting us to buy something! A soda? A car, A war? These habits have left any normative sense of harmony by the wayside, and made this dynamic perhaps THE driving social force today.

This genie has been let out of the bottle. The corrosive effects of this mega-dynamic have led to the failures of governance, of most of our institutions, we  experience today. We've all developed such deeply infantile habits that we’re unable to see our own deeper self-interests, even our own self-preservation, as of greater value than being continually condescended to.

I keep thinking what it would have been like if Paul Revere, on stepping into the saddle, had stopped to wonder if he’d worded his message properly. “The British are coming!” “Hmm… is that a bit harsh?” “I mean, how will people take it?” “I don’t want to be a downer….”

Neither did he feel the need to couch his warning as a chance for his “audience” to vicariously feel part of some stirring fantasy from some relentlessly hyped mass-entertainment. He didn’t say, “I’ll be back!” or “Do you feel lucky?” He simply warned a citizenry of a fact, “The British are coming!”

Countless examples could be taken from any slice of world history that show a similar disconnect between the way people have faced threats before and the way we now expect to be treated. Perhaps in the past, people on-the-whole were no more or less realistic, they've always had myths and fantasies to insulate their self-image, their sense of vulnerability, and cope with forces beyond their control. But rarely did these coping mechanisms fail us as badly as they are failing us now, certainly never on such a broad scale?

The Aztecs on meeting Cortez; countless native North American Nations on meeting the British, French and later Americans; had similar melt-downs. The Aborigines in Australia… But all of these were long standing cultures facing challenges to their circumstances far outside their previous experiences, leaving them precious little room or time to adjust… Hmm…

How did they respond? Briefly, and with brutal abbreviation, the Aztecs decided they were meeting one of their gods come-to-earth, conveniently a god of destruction. Cortez was eager to accommodate. Many native North Americans faced catastrophic epidemics leaving them reeling as they retreated against overwhelming odds. In the end, too many had too few resources left to do more than retreat into fantasies of a physical return to their spirit world, or just short-circuited into alcohol and drug abuse. This has become a tradition in North America for displaced and marginalized peoples ever since; a tradition now extending to many of those one would have thought of as among the privileged classes, as a look into suburbia with its locked down schools, meth labs, and chronic alcoholism will attest.

As with the list of dead rock & rollers, this list of marginalized and displaced cultures, unable to cope and adapt, all met fairly banal, stereotypical ends; apathy, and a retreat into displacing, self-destructive behaviors.

An irony may be that as we enter the new age dawning, members of these earlier displaced groups might be more likely to find hope, and a recognition of the connections with deeper realities, than will those who've prospered on the graves of their ancestors.

The reason for this might be that they were overtaken by the same storm now about to ravage us all. A storm that was able, temporarily – yes a few centuries count as temporary, even fleeting, in a human experience spanning many hundreds of thousand years – to roll over their more modest, and sustainable, accommodations to reality; but this juggernaut has lost its ability to continue. The historic coincidence of a virulently exploitative culture fueled by a copious, but one-time, abundance of accessible energy; allowed it to drastically, dramatically overshoot the fundamental planetary economy – the planet’s abilities to sustain any particular set of circumstances, given the limitations of its resources and systems.

Enormity again. I feel like someone trying to help a victim of overdose. They just want to nod out. Why must I keep bothering them? They probably chose this path to oblivion anyway. Why can’t I honor their wishes to be left alone?

Why indeed. First, let’s make a few distinctions. None of what I’m talking about is a call to survivalism, or some desire to wallow in apocalyptic visions. This isn’t about hunkering down, one against the many, or about raining down fire-and-brimstone on sinning masses. Those are variants within an array of stereotypical, symptomatic reactions to societal collapse. They’re not useful responses, just aspects of the pathology that got us here.

Like the drunken “Indian,” the freaked-out rocker, or even the furious and fed-up Weimar German, we are all in some state of toxic shock, and in need of a path through the painful symptoms of withdrawal from the addictions that got us where we are today. We need to be careful not to exacerbate the difficulties of withdrawal, difficulties that could lead us into even weaker states, states that lead us farther and farther from being able to face reality as it comes up to meet us. “The last thing I remember was a rush of air past my cheek, as my face hit the floor…”

This discussion has taken us around the conditions we need to be aware of. That this is a circuitous route is one of its virtues, as surprising as that may seem. We are so accustomed to having experts take us succinctly to the “cause of our problems,” and deftly lay out “solutions” in some “Bold Initiative!,” or Twelve Step Plan.” This kind of self-limited, linear thinking led us here, allowed us to ignore the warning signs,

"Ugh, let’s see, Is slavery a bad thing? Is it OK to wipe out whole swaths of the earth’s  flora and fauna and native populations? Does it make sense to spray poison on our lawns, fertilize-the-hell-out-of-them, and then cut them with a gas-mower once a week? Did I forget about the sprinkler? In places like Nevada?”

A small, skewed sample of the litany of warnings we’ve blithely ignored on the advice of those who’ve been so adept at compartmentalizing the world, so able to combine unprecedented abilities to make things happen with mind-boggling faculties of self-blindness to the "unintended" consequences. As a vaunted economist now spearheading our “Recovery” only recently said in answer to whether it would be prudent to consider the earth’s physical systems, and their limits, when making decisions about our economy smugly pronounced, “That’s not the right way to look at it.”

Enormity, Marshal Foch, leading French troops into battle in World War I had an eerily similar certainty concerning what the “problems” were, and what the “solutions” should be. “Send them over-the-top!” We’ve had waves of this kind of deeply ignorant hubris from all varieties of leaders over the intervening century. This has been yet another symptom we've so far failed to heed. We’ve tended to make excuses. “It’s only human nature!” “How could anyone have known…?”

There's a collective shame behind our acceptance of these individual attempts to deflect responsibility. Behind all such statements, and our blushes on hearing them, lies our own sense of culpability.  Our shame re-surfacing whenever we have turned our backs on Enormity.

9.24.2009

In the Meantime…

It's been too long since my last post.  That's a common refrain on many blogs, I'm afraid, with haunting echoes of the confessional?  Life intrudes, inspiration wanes, there can be many causes.  Let me bring you up-to-date on my situation.

Over the last weeks I've completed a short story.  I'm considering the best way to include excerpts from my fiction here, whether as written posts or as podcasts, read aloud.  Any ideas?  I've also been deep into editing Pathtree's upcoming book.  While I've continued to have ideas for posts here, I've had less and less time to devote here.  It's simply a matter of triage.

In the meantime, this other work will influence future posts.  I'm committed to this enterprise.  The manner, and matter, of what ends up here will evolve as a result of these other projects.

In the meantime, I've suffered the loss of a close friend.  Rob Wigsten, 48, the father of two teenage girls, passed away after a long illness.  He was a good friend.  He taught us all so much.  He is missed.  I hope to write more about him sometime….

PathTree holds its inaugural reception tomorrow, Friday September 25.  I urge you to join us there, info at pathtree.com.  If you can't make it, check out our web site over the coming weeks, we'll be posting frequently as things continue to ramp up.

Losing a friend, embarking on a new endeavor, looking at immense changes of all kinds looming; all this points to our common need to come together, decide what's important to us, and act on our decisions.  These are, and will continue to be, constant themes throughout this journal.

In the meantime, forgive my silences, and the brevity of this post.

While we're here, remember, any and all comments are not only welcome, but will do much to move us forward.  Add a comment, or send an e-mail.  While you're at it, pass the link on to anyone you think might be interested.  It's the best way for this circle to grow.

9.05.2009

Response to Mark Gordon's, To Undo the Folded Lie…

My partner, Mark Gordon, in his most recent post to The Conversation at PathTree.com chose to point to the anniversary of the start of WWII.  He invoked Auden's poem, September 1, 1939.  I feel it important to link to his post here, and have appended my response below. 

There is much that will overlap between what I write there on PathTree and what I write here.  Any differences will be more in nuance than obvious divergence.  For this instance, it seems the needs of both venues are in complete alignment. 


So fitting to mark this anniversary.  There is something about early September that has always held portents, at least in my lifetime….

I tend to focus more on that other September in 1914.  It began the whole train that led to ‘39 and beyond.  That it came first, or is arguably a “first cause,” is really irrelevant.  1939 did inaugurate a new era, not only in magnitude, but in kind.  The mass slaughters that were so guilelessly, even innocently unleashed in the parades of late August 1914, became true holocaust and opened the doors of our perception to visions of man’s abilities to destroy all life by the end of that struggle’s outburst in 1945.

I grew up in the shadow of that war.  All the adults in my youth had their lives shaped and measured by their relationships to that conflict.

There is something of both 1914 and 1939 about the current climate.  A confusion of willful ignorance, an innocence too tightly held to be genuine; and a delirious slide towards appeasement, a wish to do anything, besides act responsibly if only , ”the lights never go out, the music always play…”

As certainties crumble away to show themselves as mirage – as they are wont to do in such times – I find many of the old pieties about WWII to be shimmering and beginning to lose their power to act as anchors to the way reality’s unfolding “should” follow the rules. The significance seems to remain in the lead-ups, the dynamics that played out and culminated in these catastrophes even as their fairy-tale endings, meant to console us into believing that these, and every other tragic epoch, were resolved; that we are once again safely returned to a blissful rest, the rest deserved by those who “mean well.”

It seems to take a full generation, maybe two, for the visceral feel of what it’s like at a time like that – like this? – to fade away and be replaced, not by a churning sense of recognition, but by a deep and paralyzing incredulity.  We have yet to make the transition through this, this first, and perhaps most devastating aspect of a slide from delirious innocence to engaged acceptance in the active struggles any being must constantly be willing to maintain, in a give-and-take dynamic with slippery, elusive and potentially dangerous realities.

If only there was a way to stay in that moment’s awakening clarity, find ways to maintain that wary, yet thrilling sense of really living that comes when a crisis sweeps away the platitudes and commonplace that cloud our visions, and before some “Call to Action” is usurped by the pull towards hate and violence as a Righteous response.  There are these moments of choice that open up ,and give us a chance – perhaps our only chance – to chose engagement; a real life in play and counter-play with our enfolding realities instead of the apparent ease of ignorance or anger.

This is the Gift such moments bring, as hard as it is to accept that there is anything good about such moments.  It is a Gift offered only in times of the greatest need, and a Gift that is squandered at the most precarious cost.  This cost has escalated each time in the last century that it was offered and then derailed.  We are the heirs of these conditions, can we not do any better?

8.29.2009

Conimbriga

From this:
The Forum

To this:
 
The "Wall of Desperation" 

I remember visiting Conimbriga as a child.  I was back as a young man with a bride.  Back again, much later, with a wife.

Conimbriga was a place, a symbol of the reach of empire, the power of a center basking under a broad hegemon, sprawling across a continent, secure in its position, its power, its future.  But for me, from my first sight of it as a young boy, it was as a symbol, striking and poignant, of that empire’s contraction, the collapse, the fall-back of end-game.

I’ve always had a profound sense of its existing at the margins, both in distance, almost as far as one could have been from Rome and seen oneself as Roman; but also in time.  The ruins of Conimbriga date from up to when the city was abandoned in the fifth century.  It was “frozen” in time then, the ruins of the broadest expanse of the city cut and scarred by a later defensive wall, built with great haste and immeasurable toil across the sunny outer borough, using stone taken from the wealthy villas that had flourished there in the previous centuries.  This moment was captured in the silt and sedimentation of the passing millennia, a slow Pompei. 

We don’t have fresh frescos, and casts of fallen bodies overcome by a fleeting disaster; but we do have mosaic floors, and the layouts of villas, houses, baths, and the Forum, along with the wall, and the aqueduct that fed water to the city.  In one of the inner villas, just inside the wall of desperation, there was said to have been found a skeleton and a sword during early, pre-archeological digs there.  Whether this was true or a necessary fantasy, is not so important.  Standing there at the side of the villa’s courtyard, gazing down into the grave-like hole of its central pool, it is easy to imagine bloodshed there.

There is a pall over the place, no matter how sunny the day, or how luxuriant the restored plantings.  This is not a monument to the grandeur of Rome, but to its dissolution.  There hangs over it yet, after 1500 years, a sense of the shock, the surprise, and disbelief that must have been so prevalent as the entire construct, not only of Rome, but of the whole Mediterranean Ancient World, came tumbling down on their heads.  At some point, the attitude there must have gone from “Things are bad, They’ll do something about it!”  To, “Things are awful!  How can we save ourselves!” 

The new wall built – I can imagine everyone pitching in, broken nails, torn togas, panting, sweating patricians side-by-side with slaves and tradesmen, men and women – all working to build up the last ditch defense, the narrower perimeter.  Then, a last defeat, the survivors leaving a burnt-out shell of their city, probably in bondage to the Suevians, Germanics come down from the north.

Life persisted for a time, the shattered city must have sheltered some, but relatively quickly life passed the ruined remains by.  Aeminium, a smaller Roman town, became the new city, Coimbra.  Life went on, and after a few hundred years Conimbriga was just a rough spot on the terrain, situated next to a gorge.  Later still, a village grew up next to it, a primitive place of stone huts and farmer’s fileds.  Fields and an orchard of olive trees spread over the rough ground on top of the ruins, blending them into the bucolic life of a much less grand age.

The lesson of Conimbriga is in the sacrifice of part of the city in that desperate last ditch effort to save it.  Defensive walls, built to protect a place and things will fail.  Within a generation the city was abandoned anyway.

Was Coimbra’s location better?  It had water communication along the Mondego, a good hill-top for defense, but also it did not have the baggage, both of the old elites themselves and of their precious stuff.

Conimbriga spoke to me, fifty years ago, I heard it.  The times have changed around it. The fascist dictatorship, still carrying on with a provincial, tepid version of Mussolini’s Pride in all that was Rome – somewhere between the deadly seriousness of Hitler, and the fuzzy nostalgia and lazy rationalizations of some mafia Don; has been long gone.  It faded into its irrelevance as its story no longer held thrall.  The ruins have been spruced up, a curious oxymoron, as EU e-currency was lavished on excavation, enlarging the museum and decorating the grounds with plantings, restored mosaics and metal roofs over the most spectacular villa carefully brought to light from its long exile outside the “new” wall.

None of the changes have quieted the old voices.  Try as they might to muffle them, in ways the Salazar's repression was unable to accomplish as well.  The somber tragedies of hunger and fear in Portugal fifty years ago made a more honest backdrop for what those ruins have to say.

They are patient, the stones have sat there for so long already.  They have no need for insistence, they don’t care if we heed them or not.  But still, their voices are chilling, and their message has not been so relevant – what a deflated term that is, its value sucked away by decades of hyperbole – so relevant as they are today.  Their mute warnings of the trajectory of a long skid from first unease, through panic and desperation to final realization and dissolution, like tire tracks ending at a torn railing, or blood turning black in the sand….

8.07.2009

Author, Authority

I keep returning to the questions surrounding these two terms. I’m a writer, and therefore aspire to Author, have in a limited sense been one with my book on Design, but here I’m talking about Author of Fiction, the capitals are semi-ironic, just as my thoughts on the subject are semi-muddled.

I spend a lot of my time trying to come to grips with the world’s gatekeepers. I am most concerned these days with the way elites are cratering all around us. The dynamics surrounding the accretion of authority, versus its holders capacity to use that authority well, has never been so wildly skewed to produce bad results as it is today. The tendency, in this situation, is to discount the very idea of authority, experts, elites of all kinds. If the current crop is so bad, then perhaps the whole concept is bankrupt as well.

I’ve spent most of my life thinking as a designer. The root of design is desegno, to draw. As a designer one is constantly drawing, but the physical act of drawing is only a manifestation of the conceptual act of making distinctions, drawing distinctions. Look at Genesis, the first act described there is the separation of the light from the dark, first by creating the light, and then by placing it in relationship with the dark, cleaving the void; there follows a list of finer distinctions; placing and relating each element into the greater whole.

This “First” story puts the act of desegno as the prime, the first, action in a first story. The identification of this action with God, whatever one believes on that subject, can be seen as placing this action, the ability to create and make distinctions, as the activity with the highest priority, the one without which the rest cannot find a place.

This may be seen as self-serving, I identify myself with a certain activity, and then find a rationale for claiming it as the highest calling. Particularly if we see design only in the light of the “profession,” or group of professions that have accrued around the concept in the last century. It smacks of a particularly pitiful delusion of grandeur to equate what we’ve come to know of as design, and designers, with something so exalted. Another instance when our disgust with an elite has colored our perceptions of a broader sphere of action, another that has been trivialized by its current practitioners. My purpose is to connect myself with an aspiration that I find central to life, and to broadcast my sense of its validity, why I've dedicated so much effort and time in that direction.

While these questions have loomed large for me, there have been many small stones strewn along my path. In this, as in any discussion, they have represent the repeated need to stop and define terms, to leave the paths of efficient communication, in which everyone is familiar with the terminology, with what the words mean; and stumble along, filling in “what I mean by that,” and “No, that’s not what the term really means….” This path is strewn with minor stumbles, and veers around medium obstacles, and runs along a dangerous precipice on one side, and a blank wall of indifference on the other. Might as well get comfortable with it….

This leads me back to the point, an author’s authority. Why do we give it? It is bestowed by readers, cannot be taken upon oneself. Certain voices have developed levels of interest and trust in their readers that create a sense of “authority.” This has been confused with the other usages, with power figures who can coerce and control; with “experts” – I cannot leave the quotes off that one – who accrue badges of authority, and have paths opened to them to influence the others, the controllers. The relationship of authority to power is central to the distinction. Authorial authority presupposes no direct connection to power, neither to those who wield it, or those who curry its favor. That is not to say that many have not traded on their authority to gain power or influence, but that such connections are made after the fact, and have – if any – a negative impact on their true authority.

This is moral authority in a way, but not the way we usually think of it – another pebble to stub our toes against. The same distinctions can be made between those who wield moral authority and those who have it. The same dynamic in relationship to power prevails here. We end up sidestepping, making little progress perhaps, by calling it simply moral authority.

I return to this issue again and again, because these questions are central to my tasks, as a writer, as a designer, as an individual attempting to find a place, and make a contribution in this world. I have found the greatest guidance from those to whom I’ve given this kind of authority over me, and as I mature, I find I have more and more of a desire, and a personal need, to establish such a position for myself as a means to create the kind of legacy I’d like to leave behind.

There, that was a loose patch of rocks, a stick, and a pool of mud on that last bit of the trail! Let’s see if we can regain our balance!… No, let’s just push ahead.

This brings up another aspect of this question, one that constantly comes up. The question of trust in the other direction, from writer to reader. One of the few benefits of an earlier alignment between the forms of society and its activities, when it was possible to imagine that there was a “consensus” of what it meant to be an educated reader, the expectation a writer had that he – and he most often was a he – would find his audience, and they would understand him. That consensus is weakened today. I don’t mourn it in most respects, but I do fear that in the throes of creative destruction we have tended to go too far in allowing the positive, and perennial, yearning behind those withered forms to atrophy as well.

Another detour, or perhaps a turn in a maze. I keep coming back to a sense that whether in coming to grips with reality in all its broad aspects, and finely grained particulars; or in this one question regarding authority, that what I am always fighting for is the quality of looking and listening for quiet hints that provide us the earliest inklings of where things are heading, instead of falling for the tumult and dust of the broad and busy road. Established consensus, is always out of date. Whatever is broadly “known” is probably no longer true, just because of the time it’s taken to be disseminated widely, and the errors of transmission it’s accumulated along the way. Take the old experiment, say, “I’m cold, pass it along.” By the time this has reached the hundredth listener, I am no longer cold, and I would not recognize what they have been told on my behalf if I heard it.

What I trust in my own perceptions of the quiet hints that have not fallen into the mass maw of “understanding,” mirrors what I find valuable in the voices I find authorial, and what I hope to gain for my own voice. It is an ongoing tension between what is graspable, and an ultimate conviction that anything that matters is unknowable in the sense of one being able to hold onto it, to grasp it, and keep it safe. As with all of life, it can only be held loosely in the experience of it, we continue to “spend” it as we gain it, like the oxygen we inhale or the nourishment we take. We can no more grasp, and keep, our constructs than we can keep yesterday’s lunch, or our next breath.

Why I am writing here is tied directly to these questions. I continue to seek the vestiges of the older outlets, partly out of habit. These were the paths taken by those before me, finding a “publisher,” finding an editor, finding an “imprimatur.” There is strong precedent there, hundreds of years of tradition. But I don’t just think I continue to respect that path for those reasons alone, I also hold onto a sense that there has yet not been developed a new path that allows for the kind of concerted effort, the long and slow distillation of experience and expression that has been possible within that tradition. To say that what Cervantes started, and has been ongoing for all these centuries, is outmoded, smacks of too great a conceit. Especially when the most visible alternatives are so thin, and truly lacking in substance.

Current conversations, ranging from mere “pings,” to longer, but unmediated “posts” – like this one – don’t replace the long form. They increase my hunger for what they are unable to provide, just as they feed my curiosity over their effects on our society, and culture, going forward.

One thing I feel both paths share, when done well, is authenticity. Together they may provide the full range of what that can mean. It is authentic, up to a point, to ping “I’m here!” over and over, but is that enough? There is value in creating in a “garrett,” but if your creations don’t get out, that is surely not sufficient either.

At the start, I specified "Author of Fiction.” Why do I make that distinction, draw that line? This was my intended topic today, though it’s taken so long to get back to it! I’m afraid now to rush it, and give it short shrift. Still, let’s risk another stumble.

The second archetypal act that makes us human is the story. Picture a different Genesis tale, a troop of early hominids. Someone in authority has pointed in a particular direction, made a distinction, “We will go there, not there.” If they chose wisely, this was as much an affirmation of a consensus as an act of authority; alignment of that kind should be an attribute of leadership in a well functioning society. This path allowed a certain leeway for exploration and contingency. At the end of the day, someone, or more than one voice ,was raised in the telling of stories. This was the other fundamental act of a community’s expression. It kept their purpose, and their sense of destiny, in front of its members; it allowed that sense to evolve over time, at a pace with the changes in the surrounding conditions, without loosing sight of what had come before.

Just as design, desegno, is that first act; so is writing fiction the continuation of that second primal act. Both of these tasks have been modified over time, necessarily, though not always wisely. The second has evolved into the writing of fiction, its dissemination via publication as physical books to be read in a concerted act of purposeful “leisure.” This is the equivalent to the time spent around the fire, that time of repose, curiosity and introspection. The ongoing discussion these stories breed, can have many equivalents today, from the book club, and the occasional face to face discussion among readers, to the various online virtual gatherings, of which this one is a part.

There is, or will be, a way for these perennial needs to be met, although as with anything else, we cannot rely on “They” to do something to perpetuate it. It is up to us to discover what that synthesis will be, what are the various elements and their proportions, and how they can come together, and be vital, and robust moving forward.

7.31.2009

The Age of Wishfulness

The Age of Wishfulness is winding down. The genii is running out of oil. The lid of necessity is lowering as the power of oil to hold it at bay begins to lose force. This is both a great tragedy, and a great opportunity, though not in the knee-jerk positivist way we have grown accustomed to finding “Silver Linings” behind every adversity. It is a great tragedy, because great suffering will come of this. It is a great opportunity because, the yearning for truth will lose its hallucinatory unreality; once the age of wishfulness loses its hold, it will no longer be an aberration to doubt that something-for-nothing is not a basis for living our lives.

One of the greatest challenges I find in these days, now that I’ve dropped a self-imposed censorship of my views, has been a difficulty communicating with many people I would expect to be natural allies, bright people; who have been connected, and have made successful careers. They see the same problems arising, they look for ways to proceed. Yet, when I attempt to break through the levels of wishfulness that encase their life experiences, and cushion their world views, they balk. The natural tendency in that situation is to back-off, soften the message, find a more palatable route towards making connection. The idea is that only once that connection is made, no matter what the level of co-option required to reach it, only then may we be able to slowly bring them around.

I’m beginning to doubt this tactic, to doubt the entire premise. It smacks of enabling. It makes no sense to me anymore. When the greatest difficulty lying between where we are, and some action that may lead to a better result than would otherwise occur, is the sleep-walking attitude of the most capable people in face of deep existential crises; then how can coddling that sleep-walking be part of an effective course towards removing this block?

We see this attitude everywhere. It has grown out of the infantilization at the heart of consumer culture. It reflects the level to which narcissism has been elevated into a defensible norm within this culture. Lest anyone think I am unfairly targeting their particular brand of consumer culture – one of the most widespread symptoms of this trend has been a defensive self-victim-hood embraced by the nominally powerful to cover over their inability to act effectively – I consider all of the worlds cultures today to be acting as subsets of an over-all consumer culture. Whether a particular group is benefiting or subjugated, their assumptions are all grounded today in the tenets of consumerism. Boosters and opponents, all in a merry dance around a world view they will defend or oppose in a polar attraction, in their own minds at least, until reality has beaten the notion out of them.

Most, hell, all of my own contacts have been on the booster side, among people who have in large part benefited, as the term is normally applied, from the leading edge of consumerism. I’ve been in this clad myself, would not have survived to adulthood, would have been literally inconceivable without the oil century. Within my circles, it is rare to find anyone with whom I have not had this problem.

I attribute my own perspective to accidents of birth, and certain traumas of early life that gave me a particular combination of qualities and experiences; that have shaped my viewpoint, my instinctive perspectives, from an early age. Many of those early experiences could have been fatal, either physically or psychically. By some accident, and luck, I survived them. What this has given me has been of great use to me, although so far none of that “shows.” It has led to years of self-induced marginalization that by some accident again, has helped me to see through the too-good-to-be-true. It has given me a long experience in not having “my way.” This has led to a high tolerance for the unpleasant, and a low tolerance for wishfulness.

Communication, we use that word to describe a panoply of activities that coalesce around the act of transferring information from one person to another, one group to another, one expert to the masses. As with so much of our language it has been burried within the consumerist mindset. It is a profession, there are courses, and experts. As with every other honest human impulse that has come under the consumerists’ sway, it has been co-opted and twisted away from its honest meaning, and reduced to jargon.

A tenet of “communication” as a subset of “marketing,” the greater good to which it has been subsumed, used as a tool; is that we make it easy for a “target” to hold onto their assumptions. The desire is to modify behavior at some level below the cognitive so the target is manipulated, either unknowingly – the ideal – or at least, unwittingly. To frontally question assumptions in one’s listeners is to court disaster. In the complex physics of propaganda and manipulation, there are countless paths. We may annoy, cajole, entice our way to success, but the laws of the enterprise don’t allow for open challenge.

Having lived our entire adult lives, and having been brought up in the infantilizing precincts of primary and secondary education; we have not only become accustomed to these rules, but we demand that they be maintained. We have lost the ability to face any challenge to our assumptions, and not see in it a direct attack on our very cores. However resilient we might feel, whatever strengths we might have, we react as though such a challenge would destroy us, as some kryptonite to which we have no immunity.

People dying of hypothermia relate – those who have survived – that the hardest part is resisting the wish to just fall asleep. The most pernicious affect of the cold is a sapping of the will-to-live. Self-preservation evaporates, and the greatest goal imaginable is to fall asleep. This is an immensely powerful instinct. It may be one of the final mercies built into a biological entity, that when struggle is no longer useful, this wish for sleep takes over. A final mercy when it is reached in truly fatal circumstances, but a tragic waste when it is jumped to as a hasty conclusion when there is still much fight left in us.

What is true in the solitude of one’s final moments is also in effect within the feedback mechanisms of groups. The ancient Greek idea of Pan, that he spread a delirium of frantic paralysis, a thrashing of activity that replaces effective action, is real. It is to be feared, its effects can be worse than the crises that may have brought it on, yet it is a powerful force that takes great effort to resist. That resistance needs to come from within, it is a trait that one must develop, it is a sign of maturity.

The received wisdom is to avoid panic. We are instructed not to cry “Fire!” in a theater. Such an attitude has its places, but if there is a fire?…

The admonition to avoid panics is convenient, if one stays within a manipulative stance towards others. If other people are objects to us, then it is in our interest to sway them to our will, and panic is, by nature, uncontrollable. Fetishizing the avoidance of bad news, to avoid panic; is useful in the deepening and maintaining of infantilization within a group one wants to manipulate. The panic of panic, the cultivation of an aversion to the very notion of the unpleasant as the negative side of a value judgment that puts the protection of our wishes as the ultimate good, does maintain a malleable population, up to a point.

We are at the edge of a precipice for the constituency that has built up around the accident of access to a convenient and abundant source of fossilized energy. Those who have made their lives within a successful accommodation to those conditions are in the most difficult position vis letting go of the habits of mind and action, that have worked so well in the past. It is unfair – there are worse things – to impute nefarious import to their actions as they resist abandoning what has worked in the past. But however it is characterized, the result is an effective block against moving forward, and adapting, and accommodating to the new realities that will make themselves felt, whatever one’s wishes.

Anyone who’s been in a dysfunctional relationship knows how much energy gets sucked into the vortex of mincing around the minefields of delusion put up by the addict. The mechanism here is the same, and I think, the answers to dealing with it here should also be the same. Bring the delusions to light. Make the delusional uncomfortable in the maintenance of the lie. Don’t engage in any attempts to argue the point, as though it were a reasonable position to hold delusional views, but firmly resist such engagement since it only perpetuates the power of the delusion. Act as though it is a lapse of reason, and a relinquishing of responsibility to maintain delusional thinking, and reward engagement that puts the delusion behind you. Expect to be treated as an adult, and treat the other as one too, as a subject, not an object.

There is so much to be done, so much that can still be done. Each moment that passes, doors close, we lose potential fields of action, our horizons of potential close in. The longer we struggle harder to maintain our desires to be wishful, instead of learning ways to be thoughtful, mindful, pro-active, adaptive; the greater the tragedy ahead. It is wishful to expect something-for-nothing. Abandoning that attitude will not remove obstacles, or eliminate bad outcomes, but it will help us be able to face our challenges as actors engaged in the outcomes of our fates, instead of mere objects on which greater forces play out at their whim.

Scratch through the prickly, brittleness of the wishful, and you just might find the effective action of the potentially heroic. Not as that term is qualified within fantasy, but as it has always played out in reality; when people have stood up to their plight, eyes open to what is at stake, and made truthful efforts on their own behalf. This, sadly as with so much else, needs to be debrided of the noxious effects of recent fantasy, and wishfulness; before we can see what it really means to be heroic, against the tawdry debasement that currently passes for it.

7.26.2009

Horizons…

As I was setting up this blog, I got to the box on the form asking me for the title. I had not given this much thought. The jump from intention to action had been quick, following a long gestation; but in that moment, I had rushed on ahead of myself. I picked up Strunk & White, on my desktop where it always sits, a talisman and guide for many years; a memento of when I had been lucky enough to meet Mr. White, years ago in Maine, and sit in his kitchen soaking in who he had become late in his long life as a writer, looking for hints, the residues of something that might help me find my way on a path I held, even then, as a hidden aspiration for myself.

Opening it at random, looking for inspiration as some will turn to the Bible, or the I Ching…. Nothing jumped off the page at me. I began to suspect it had been silly to ask them for this kind of sign. After all, they had scrupulously fulfilled their intention that this work be a guide to form, they specifically steered clear of influencing content. I was glad to see they had done this so well. Elements of Style’s refusal to give me an answer was firm, yet polite, the kind of nudge Mr. White intended with all he wrote.

So I turned to my current notebook, and tried there; flipping through the most recent pages. It jumped out at me. I had a moment of recognition on seeing the phrase: Horizons of Significance. I’d come across this term in one of Michael Wesch’s videos on YouTube a week, or so, earlier. That he would have shown me my title, just as his inspiration had been pivotal in getting me to the point of starting this blog; I took as a good omen. His final nudge had been when he said that social-networking on the web is just a few, short years old, and that there “are no natives here….”

The term came to him from Paul Taylor’s Ethics of Authenticity. I looked into Taylor’s book, I’ll probably write something later on his thesis, and its connection to the wider project this blog is intended as part of; but for now, the key was the way this phrase meant something distinct to me, and something I find so important. I had an immediate recognition of this, its alignment with my own considerations had so many implications on first hearing it. So, for now, I’ll limit myself to what I’d like it to mean, and not follow a more scholarly exegesis of its sources and past meanings.

The twentieth century acted out upon the discovery of relativity, by falling into a deep crisis spiraling out from the over-all loss of a single, over-riding sense of authority. It has always seemed to me this was a petulant, adolescent response. Finding that life holds deep and radical contingency, it was as if everyone just threw up their hands, and declared as a result, nothing had meaning, nothing mattered anymore. It seemed little energy was ever expended on developing a mature perspective, while a lot went into acting out dramas of reaction at every scale from the most internal and personal, to the widest and most public of stages. Orgies of self-destruction and aggression were carried out under this banner. What seemed most centrally lacking through all of this was a sense of what I see so well expressed as looking at the horizons of significance. In a clear and quiet, a-histrionic way, this perspective lets us ask questions, and find answers; without short-circuiting, diving into nihilistic reactions, as we have, since Nietzsche had his insights, and Einstein made his discoveries.

Horizons of significance seem to me to be just the way to steer through the tensions brought on by contingency, and build on my underlying conviction of the centrality of a viable notion of truth. I’ve often thought back to Melville’s conception; life as a rope made up by twisting the strands of necessity, free will and chance. These elements of which a life is forged in a process that makes something greater of its parts, through a search for truth and meaning.

This sense that process, not outcome, passage, not destination; are most important is well suited to this form; the blog. If I trace a path from Melville to Wesch, from Ishmael to Gary Brolsma; it seems there is a common current running towards a connection between a search for personal authenticity, and a path – taken in humility – leading towards greater connections between disparate people. This current carries a common yearning, and gives us a tool for its possible incarnation; by helping us focus our searches for truth, truths and meaning; while we interact with others within a broader sphere, one without gate-keepers or inter-mediators, and their external agendas.

Ahab was a warning, an example of the long line of monomaniacs to come over the 150 years after Melville wrote him into being. The “Numa Numa Guy” is perhaps a sign of a resurgence of Ishmael’s spirit, the outsider looking for something, using his trials to find meaning, in ways those more conventionally “connected,” have long ago lost, along with any curiosity or appetite for anything beyond their comfort and its perpetuation. His silliness is not simply another symptom of the trivialization of everything, but can be seen in this light as a radical foolishness, in the way a Pan or Dionysus was foolish; signs of the need for humility in the face of great mysteries, a sign that a pose of seriousness is often a greater barrier to understanding than foolishness held in good spirit, embraced authentically while truly reaching out to others.

I hope to take a more sober path myself, more out of temperament than from any sense of superiority over the silly. There do seem to be many champions on that front all across YouTube’s broad horizons. I hope, here, to be able to strike a tone that allows for a quiet exploration of these themes, running up and down the scales, looking for ways in which the various horizons of significance can bring harmony to a life of striving for meaning, while navigating the contingencies placed in our paths.